DylPickle wrote:What I would love to see, though, is a K-Isle where every town had the same closeness and protectionist as the Blackrocks. The tension would be incredible. But, alas, it'll never happen. The one group that causes trouble will always be exterminated because a majority of people are simply subcontiously influenced with OOC morals that tend to reach extremities IG.
It wasn't necessarily OOC morality. There were clear economic and social reasons why TBR should become the enemy of other on K-Isle.
The strict control of hematite became, for obvious reasons, a sticking point for the rich/powerful/leaders of the island. As a result, it was in their interest to foster a dislike of the tribe.
The initial dislike, the stories of dreadful actions, were perpetuated by those with a reason too. neither did they complain much when the stories exaggerated through telling, as they are apt to.
The general populace hooked onto the idea of TBR as the 'enemy' (or, more accurately, the 'Other'). Not because they controlled hematite, but because they became a means of confiriming and reinforcing their own identities. TBR were the other - something which any identity requires. Who are we, if we are not someone else?
This use of the 'other' is common place in group identities. On many scales. Not least amongst national identities.
This is where it's possible to draw very interesting parralels between K-Isle identities and Europe.
It is exceptionally difficult to define a European identity. The cultures and societies which Europe encompasses are very diverse, often divergent. But, at the same time, it is useful to be able to define and relate to a European identity (if one lives in Europe), for political, social and economic reasons.
In the past, during the formation of the 'idea of Europe', the political elite of Europe employed similar tactics as the policitical elite of K-Isle. The goals of the European eliute were social identification for forseen political and econmic gain (the actuality of those gains is another discussion).
Europe was construed, in part, as not being Africa/Asia/America, as being cultured (not barbaric), as being Christian (not Muslim). Turkey, Russia, Northern Africa and other neighbours were considered to be the 'Other' through which a European identity could be reinforced.
Whether this use of TBR as an identity-confirming 'Other' was a planned or fortunate by-product of the fosterment of hatred by the elite of K-Isle, I do not know. But it happened.
By portraying TBR as the 'Other', Kwor, Karnon and the DeDannans had a common ground upon which to come together. If not being the only reason for those ties, it certainly became one of the defining factors, and a great strengthener of those ties. It was possible not only for individuals to see themselves as Kworians but as Kworians and K-Islanders, allies of Karnon and the DeDannans.
TBR eventually left the island. But the hate, the need for TBR to be the enemy, followed them. It had clearly become much more than a dislike, by the elite, of their control of hematite. It had become ingrained in the psyche of K-Islanders.
It was a natural continuation of events that TBR should be hunted down. The issue, like these things are apt, snowballed. Beyond the control of those who had started it, to the extent that a war (with minimal justification) became the most obvious option, so that those who would normally be opposed to such things (including one of my characters) found themselves agreeing with, and following the turn of events.
Now, TBR are all but gone. The forest is under control of K-Isle once again, and Burgeo represents a land of wealth on the horizon.
The Church of the Holy Father is waning, its once magnificent structures lying unused and unseen - whatever common ground the Church once provided, it does no longer.
The DeDannans, from what I hear, seem to be disintegrating, or at least comming to terms with new leaders, and are thus without the capacity to engage in Island-wide issues.
The Karnon Imperials have a lot on their plate. They have expanded to encompass the Forest and the Port. As the Imperials are apt to do, even in peace time, they are expanding their armed forces, and (last I heard) their navy is said to be comparable to that of Kwor's great forces.
Kwor may not be at her peak, but she still goes strong. Great names of long-ago are gone, and no longer in the thoughts of the bustling metropolis. The decentralised guild system continues to function, and the council, with a clear and active figurehead for the town, continues to direct the goings-on.
Alongside this, there are the KORT and the ever-present possibility that KDF, or another internal faction may grow in power and size.
With the loss of TBR, the thoughts of the elite have turned inwards. The alliances remain, but any closeness has gone.
Is it still possible for an individual to feel as much a K-Islander as before? Will the alliance formed to oppose the Tribe hold? Or are the powers of K-Isle to become more insular, and possibly to become competitors for Burgeo?
(This should have been a 'Zine article... I always knew there could be parallels between academic political theories of the real-world and the Cantr microcosm...)