Star Wars Mafia

[Zanthos]

personally, i think the traitor is fine to leave in, but remove the need to kill the traitors. In all other mafia games, besides medieval, the traitor didnt count for mafia numbers.

[trexdino]

well, okay then

also, are you joining?

[Zanthos]

sure.

[mikki]

I personally think that you should run the game how you want to.. It is your game.. Add what roles you want to..

[trexdino]

okay then, the mafia ninja, since there is no bomb is being changed to a role I thought of. Tell me what you think-
Mafia Time Keeper- Once per game has the power to completly reset the day. All tasks undone, votes destroyed, and deadline reset for 48 hours.

What do people think? Is it to unfair?

[Voltenion]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! Don't, please, Don't start the game at night! It's unfair and very very very stupid. It's pointless... You'll lose a player, who didn't even had the time to play. WHICH SUCKS, besides you'd go blind too if they killed someone at night. They'd always kill the smartest person, always! And that will suck for them. Start at day. The only thing I like more from these mafias here that the ones I play in RL, is the fact that no one gets bored to death at the beggining...

*brings an angry mob, all revolting and bla bla bla... Of course a little card says "just my opinion, sir trex."*

oh and I'm in

[trexdino]

I think that is why we stopped doing it like that. Somepeople would be killed before the game started, and that used to always be Bowser. For this issue, I will put it up to all of you to decide.

[mikki]

I think it should be started in the day time.. like the other games..

[Voltenion]

you know my vote...

*looks at Dog* I'm winning

[Dogonabun]

The person who gets shot n1 doesn't lose anything. He didn't waste any time or effort into the game, so i don't see why he would be bitter about being shot.
Besides, it's better than having a good killed day 1- which is what ALWAYS happens, because the mafia carries more influence on the first day because of a higher amount of united numbers.
Edit: Hell, if you want to, have the first night be a no-kill night, where all non killing roles get to go. I'm always on the good side so I'm fine with a benefit.
Edit on the edit: I also agree with Zanthos. if you're going to have someone be uncatchable by the cop, he should also not need to be killed.
Mikki, we're making suggestions as to how to improve the game. Is there something wrong with that?

[Voltenion]

You are right... no big deal to get killed right away... except, maybe... not playing?

And good is killed on the first day because people are usually voting in this spirit: "Weeeell, it's day one, let's just vote and get on with this" If you take some time and think, make everyone talk, evil always says something wrong.. They are in such pressure, they always do.

[Dogonabun]

Yeah, but the majority of people want a quick lynch the first day, and most people get what they want in a vote.

[Sparkle]

I too think it should start during the day. It gives us all a chance to roleplay and complete tasks before we get down to business which the information we find at night...

But, as Mikki says, this is your game, your choice.

[mikki]

I didn't say anything was wrong with the suggestions. I just think it is funny that you are always the one 'suggesting' how the game should be run. You do it in every game there is advertised when it comes to mafia type of games.. I guess the way I think is that it is his game and should be played the way that he wants to run it. I look at it as if you want the game to be run a certain way you can start another one yourself.. Again.. just my opinion in the matter..


Oh and thank you Sparkle for agreeing with me on it being Trex's game..

[Sparkle]

I try.