Religion

General chitchat, advertisements for other services, and other non-Cantr-related topics

Moderators: Public Relations Department, Players Department

Do you agree?

Poll ended at Sat Apr 22, 2006 9:23 pm

Disagree with 1, 2 & 3
15
48%
Disagree with 2 & 3
0
No votes
Disagree with 3
2
6%
I don't wanna take sides
6
19%
Agree with all
8
26%
 
Total votes: 31
User avatar
Pie
Posts: 3256
Joined: Sun Jun 19, 2005 3:30 am
Location: the headquarters of P.I.E.

Postby Pie » Sat Dec 02, 2006 7:30 pm

DELGRAD wrote:
saztronic wrote:Actually, atheism is a religion, if by "religion" you mean believing in something that can't be proven.

You can't prove there is no god, so if that's what you believe, welcome to the world of the religious. There's nachos and ginger ale on the buffet table. The atheists hang out in the back, mostly, but watch out for the holy rollers on your way down there.


Your is means nothing to me. It is only text format.

How can the denial that a god or gods exist be construed as religion.
I was only saying that whatever a person believes is for them true, but only for them.

For me the idea of the existence of a god or gods is ridiculous.

My ,"religion" as you say, is for me and only me and no one else.

Everyone has a differnt way of thinking of things and they are right in whatever way they think. So for whatever you think atheism is a religion and for me it is not.

We are both right and both wrong.

You ever hear an atheist say that? As I said one is for the one.

I will not defend my position as you should not yours, but you will do as you do.


Now there are a few presumptions that I will make about you'r statement. you are stating that there are no universal truths in the world. you are stating that nothing exists. I get this by the small sentence "Your is means nothing to me." and "We are both right and both wrong."

And I will defend my position as you should, but you will do as you do. For, if you just ignore me, that would be considerd ignorance, and you would be doing, and being everything people have called me when talking about this issue, such as ignorant.

And anyway, Evolution and athiesim do believe in an invisibal supernatural force, called phisics.
Pnumerical Intuitiong Engyn
Paranormal Investigation Exorsism
Porcupine Interspecies Extra_poison
Pick In Enter

... The headquarters of P.I.E.!!!
User avatar
deadboy
Posts: 1488
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2006 6:41 pm
Location: England

Postby deadboy » Sat Dec 02, 2006 11:19 pm

Atheism is counted as a religion, and your logic is flawed. You say that everyone is right as there is no such thing as is, saying that everything is right and wrong. (Well for one this is a paradox, as by your logic this means that someone is right in thinking that there is no such thing as right or wrong, and for this to be true there has to be such a thing as a right) Clearly everything is not right and wrong at the same time, and two people with conflicting ideas, for example god is real or god is not real, as they conflict, duhhh. In their own heads the wrong person can still believe themselves to be right, even if given proof that they are wrong. But that is called denial, and it does not make them right.

Well anyway, I am never, ever, going to tell either side of an argument that they are wrong to continue arguing, as changing my mind about things always feels good.
"Our enemies are innovative and resourceful, and so are we. They never stop thinking about new ways to harm our country and our people, and neither do we" - George W. Bush
west
Posts: 4649
Joined: Mon Aug 25, 2003 5:23 pm

Postby west » Mon Dec 04, 2006 8:15 am

deadboy wrote:Atheism is counted as a religion, and your logic is flawed. You say that everyone is right as there is no such thing as is, saying that everything is right and wrong. (Well for one this is a paradox, as by your logic this means that someone is right in thinking that there is no such thing as right or wrong, and for this to be true there has to be such a thing as a right) Clearly everything is not right and wrong at the same time, and two people with conflicting ideas, for example god is real or god is not real, as they conflict, duhhh. In their own heads the wrong person can still believe themselves to be right, even if given proof that they are wrong. But that is called denial, and it does not make them right.

Well anyway, I am never, ever, going to tell either side of an argument that they are wrong to continue arguing, as changing my mind about things always feels good.


See, if you would all just admit that you're Discordians we could call this thread settled. :roll:
I'm not dead; I'm dormant.
User avatar
oddedd
Posts: 420
Joined: Tue Sep 23, 2003 6:32 pm
Location: Aberdeen, Scotland

Postby oddedd » Sat Dec 09, 2006 5:25 pm

wow super deep poll
When you're falling off a cliff you might as well try to fly.
DELGRAD
Posts: 411
Joined: Thu Apr 27, 2006 4:38 am

Postby DELGRAD » Thu Jan 11, 2007 3:50 am

Pie wrote:And anyway, Evolution and athiesim do believe in an invisibal supernatural force, called .


Thread all dead and done. :D :twisted: :D None no more it ain't.

Physics tested and proved. ERR your phisics is physics. Took me all of three seconds to check withh online dictionary for spell right.
SupNat Forces not! Can't test what is not there.

And by "We are both right and both wrong" There is no set fact in opinion. An opinion is only true to the one of the opinion. So I am right in one opinion while you are wrong in the same, WELL it is my opinion. You are right in one opinion while I am wrong in the same, WELL it is your opinion.


To anyone saying "an opinion is a belief"... BIG BULL DUNG. My opinion is my view and or my personal view of things.



I am really drunk so don't kill or flame be too bad.

DUNG! Should have I brought this back? HMMM... I think... Yes
Last edited by DELGRAD on Thu Jan 11, 2007 3:59 am, edited 1 time in total.
Science teacher: "good morning class"
students groan
Science teacher: "Today we will be learning about intelligent design"
Little Billy: "OH GOD"

First quoted in the NationStates forum on 10/14/05.

http://washingtonvil.myminicity.com
User avatar
Pie
Posts: 3256
Joined: Sun Jun 19, 2005 3:30 am
Location: the headquarters of P.I.E.

Postby Pie » Thu Jan 11, 2007 3:58 am

Well, I personally don't think so... but then again it's to late now.

Opinions don't matter, true. But we aren't talking about opinions, were talking about facts. And in the world of facts, not everything can be correct, becaus that would break the logic-law of contradiction.
Pnumerical Intuitiong Engyn

Paranormal Investigation Exorsism

Porcupine Interspecies Extra_poison

Pick In Enter



... The headquarters of P.I.E.!!!
DELGRAD
Posts: 411
Joined: Thu Apr 27, 2006 4:38 am

Postby DELGRAD » Thu Jan 11, 2007 4:01 am

Pie wrote:Well, I personally don't think so... but then again it's to late now.

Opinions don't matter, true. But we aren't talking about opinions, were talking about facts. And in the world of facts, not everything can be correct, becaus that would break the logic-law of contradiction.


How are opinions fact? In my opinion my genitals are of gold? Is that fact.

Prove my opinion as contradiction. You can not as it is my opinion. Yea yea you opinion contradicts mine, but not by, but by you. Round and round she may go.
Last edited by DELGRAD on Thu Jan 11, 2007 4:04 am, edited 1 time in total.
Science teacher: "good morning class"

students groan

Science teacher: "Today we will be learning about intelligent design"

Little Billy: "OH GOD"



First quoted in the NationStates forum on 10/14/05.



http://washingtonvil.myminicity.com
User avatar
Pie
Posts: 3256
Joined: Sun Jun 19, 2005 3:30 am
Location: the headquarters of P.I.E.

Postby Pie » Thu Jan 11, 2007 4:03 am

I didn't say opinions are facts.

I said that we aren't talking about opinions.

We are talking about facts.

we are debating over religion, fact or not fact.

Explaining things to a drunken person is really hard...
Pnumerical Intuitiong Engyn

Paranormal Investigation Exorsism

Porcupine Interspecies Extra_poison

Pick In Enter



... The headquarters of P.I.E.!!!
DELGRAD
Posts: 411
Joined: Thu Apr 27, 2006 4:38 am

Postby DELGRAD » Thu Jan 11, 2007 4:08 am

Pie wrote:I didn't say opinions are facts.

I said that we aren't talking about opinions.

We are talking about facts.

we are debating over religion, fact or not fact.

Explaining things to a drunken person is really hard...


First i must say. Pie I like you. You push a point and not let it die. As do I, but sometimes I am to forget and make arguement later.

Religion is fiction in my opinion.

Not too drunk to argue my opinion.

I may forget this is here. See if can make a favorite.
Science teacher: "good morning class"

students groan

Science teacher: "Today we will be learning about intelligent design"

Little Billy: "OH GOD"



First quoted in the NationStates forum on 10/14/05.



http://washingtonvil.myminicity.com
User avatar
Pie
Posts: 3256
Joined: Sun Jun 19, 2005 3:30 am
Location: the headquarters of P.I.E.

Postby Pie » Fri Jan 12, 2007 2:24 am

You have you're right to an opinion.

I have mine.

If we were to debait them, I'm fairly sure I would win.

I think in these 100 pages... somewere.. I've proved that jesus has lived, died, and rose again.

With that said and done, I must say that you are being... kinda ignorant. No offence intended, just stating my opinion.

And also, I have to say that there is a difference between an opinion and a belief. An opinion deals with the er/ests. It is better, it's best, and the like. In you're opinion, athiesim is better than religion.

a beliefe is what you think is true. It is youre belife that religion is untrue.

When you talk about beliefs, not all of them can be true.

I respect you for having ideals... but sober up man.
Pnumerical Intuitiong Engyn

Paranormal Investigation Exorsism

Porcupine Interspecies Extra_poison

Pick In Enter



... The headquarters of P.I.E.!!!
west
Posts: 4649
Joined: Mon Aug 25, 2003 5:23 pm

Postby west » Fri Jan 12, 2007 3:20 am

Pie wrote:You have you're right to an opinion.

I have mine.

If we were to debait them, I'm fairly sure I would win.

I think in these 100 pages... somewere.. I've proved that jesus has lived, died, and rose again.


We are NOT starting this again.

You won't, you didn't, and happy new year.
I'm not dead; I'm dormant.
DELGRAD
Posts: 411
Joined: Thu Apr 27, 2006 4:38 am

Postby DELGRAD » Fri Jan 12, 2007 10:15 am

Pie wrote:You have you're right to an opinion.

I have mine.

If we were to debait them, I'm fairly sure I would win.

I think in these 100 pages... somewere.. I've proved that jesus has lived, died, and rose again.

With that said and done, I must say that you are being... kinda ignorant. No offence intended, just stating my opinion.

And also, I have to say that there is a difference between an opinion and a belief. An opinion deals with the er/ests. It is better, it's best, and the like. In you're opinion, athiesim is better than religion.

a beliefe is what you think is true. It is youre belife that religion is untrue.

When you talk about beliefs, not all of them can be true.

I respect you for having ideals... but sober up man.


Unless you lived during the days of the one called "jesus" you have no proof, words or otherwise. And I am speaking of the jesus that was/is the so called "son of god". Only "god" or "jesus" can prove it, but I see neither speaking.

A debate between opinions? Ha, you can not win, nor can I. My opinion is right for me and yours right for you. I do not try to prove my opinions while you may yours. Can not win or lose a debate in one that I only say, my opinion is my opinion.

Atheism better than religion? No, atheism is just my way of life. No right or wrong here. Religion is for the individual to find for themself. I simply refuse the idea of religion.

"a beliefe is what you think is true." Beliefs I may have, but none are religion. I am of mind that the idea of god or whatever is simply foolish. That such a thing can exsist is well, for the weak minded and simply can not be. As foolish as everyones cats all call each other steve and they are plotting to use catnip to rule the world and make humans their slaves. That is my "religion". Is it yours? I have 10 cats where I live. They want to enslave humans by craping and vomiting on everything. Dogs and snakes eat cats. Are they trying to rule the world and make us slaves?

You may think that I am ignorant all you wish, but that is your opinion. Your opinion is not mine.
Science teacher: "good morning class"

students groan

Science teacher: "Today we will be learning about intelligent design"

Little Billy: "OH GOD"



First quoted in the NationStates forum on 10/14/05.



http://washingtonvil.myminicity.com
User avatar
deadboy
Posts: 1488
Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2006 6:41 pm
Location: England

Postby deadboy » Fri Jan 12, 2007 2:06 pm

Pie wrote:
DELGRAD wrote:GOD JESUS means nothing. It Is but A legend of lies of many thousands of years.

That is of the old way. I have been an atheist no less than 28 years and no demonds posses me. I have free will over all. Same as the free will you can have if you wish it so.


I must sorely disagree with this, and also state that again you are being ignorant (I mean no offence, just to tell you my opinion) By not stating any proof or any slight evidenced of such.


I must be the worst christian in the world ;)

There is plenty of evidence that christianity is merely lies, and it is circular belief, I believe in god because it tells me to in the bible, and I believe in the bible because it is the word of god. The fact that it has changed over the last few thousand years is fact.

Now, I'd love to quote why much "belief" is "ignorant", rather than him, but I can't find my Darren Brown book, so I'll sum it up. Religion works on the principle of finding times when it is correct, and raising them up, whilst ignoring times things went wrong. Take for example you Pie, as you are such a devout christian I assume you pray? Well, think back to a few prayers you had recently, right, now, the ones you are likely to raise up are those that were answered, or didn't need to be answered, and you will say that is definitive proof of god's existance because he answered a prayer. However, we ignore those times that prayers weren't answered, and frankly in order to have any kind of "evidence" you have to see this as evidence that god doesn't exist, despite the fact that some of your prayers were answered, as this proves them to merely be chance.

An example that doesn't revolve around religion. There was an experiment where they were fed from a tube whilst they were in a small enclosed space. At first they tried it with the feeding periods coming at random intervals, defined by a computer. Each chicken saw that one thing they did caused the feeder to feed them, although of course it had no effect whatsoever, and so every single chicken began to go through its own ritual of movements and noises in order to make the feeder feed them. They didn't notice that quite often when they performed their rituals nothing happened, their brain only relised that at some points it did work, and so despite the fact that it had nothing to do with the outcome they still had rituals. Next they performed it at set intervals, every half-hour or so, and despite the fact that there was a clear system to it, a new set of chickens still formed their own rituals to make the feeder feed them.

This experiment was then repeated on humans, children to be precise. A clown was given a bag of sweets and told first to give sweets out to the children at random intervals. The children, like the chicken, created their own rituals to make the clown give them sweets, for example kissing his nose, or doing little dances. This of course had no effect on the outcome, there were many times they did it when nothing happened, but they reason that because sometimes the timing was the same they were making a difference. They then did it with set timings, and, again, like the chicken, found the same result, the children formed rituals.

Now lets go back to prayers. They are a ritual to make things happen because at some points the thing that you want to happen does happen because of it. But the fact that it doesn't everytime is -proof- that thr ritual has no effect.

Now lets take the morals of this and apply them to religion as a whole. They believe that because some things, perhaps in the bible, or perhaps in real life situations, conform to what the religion tells you, they ignore everything that -doesn't- go right, and the things that are -wrong- with their holy scriptures, and the prayers that -arn't- answered, despite the fact that these things are also certainly evidence against the religion.

They do not work like Science. Science tries constantly to prove itself wrong because you -cannot-, and I mean -cannot- prove something true by finding examples of when something is true, you can only prove something true by finding that there is no evidence that it isn't true. (Take my question about cards with numbers and letters on each side in the brain questions thread. It works on this principle)
"Our enemies are innovative and resourceful, and so are we. They never stop thinking about new ways to harm our country and our people, and neither do we" - George W. Bush
User avatar
Elros
Posts: 1511
Joined: Sat Jul 22, 2006 5:41 pm
Location: South Carolina, USA

Postby Elros » Sat Apr 14, 2007 5:37 am

Of course God does not give us every single thing we ask for, but he always hears our prayers and answers with a yes, no, or maybe later.

What kind of father would give their kid every single thing he ever asked for, even when he knew it would not be best for the kid? That would be a bad father! God knows what is best for us, and what we need and don't need. When we ask for something he gives it to us out of what is best for our interests. Sometimes we cannot see why God doesn't give us something(just like a child can not always understand why his fatehr doesn't give him something or let him do something), but we can rest assured that he has our best interest in mind.
Every action has a consequence.
User avatar
Dee
Posts: 1985
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2004 8:06 am

Postby Dee » Sat Apr 14, 2007 10:45 am

I believe in that, too, Elros. God won't answer all of our prayers, but He sure does listen to us when we ask something from him. He'll give us what we need and what He knows is best for us. If your prayers not answered, then you should believe that something better than what you asked for is waiting for you in Heaven.

At least, that's what I believe... And a lot of us, as Muslims, believe in that too.

Return to “Non-Cantr-Related Discussion”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest