Cantr II Discussion Forum

Hello!

Can anyone tell me what the difference is between timber and wood or if there is a difference at all. I guess I would have known if it was translated in dutch, but since it isn't... Could anyone explain? Thanks.

Well timber isn't real for one thing.... *runs off before staff finds him, yelling* It ain't reaaal!

Um...IRL, timber would be wood in it's rawest form...tree trunks and such (I think).

In cantr, timber is a resource that likely exists somewhere, but wood is the common and important resource...as far as I know, timber is only usable to make the log cabin.

Timber was also added to the game relatively recently, whereas wood has most likely been around since the beginning.

Wrong, I'm afraid.

TImber is prepared wood. The log cabin should really use raw wood, and other wood buildings the timber. Timber is the same as lumber - wood prepared for use, not raw wood.

For sources:

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=timber
http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=lumber
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timber
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lumber

If the log cabin is using timber, something is highly wrong.

Thankfully nobody noticed my typo.

Smarty pants >.>;;

Revanael wrote:Wrong, I'm afraid.

Timber is prepared wood.

Nope. Timber is the name used at all points of the process except usually the most highly processed products. Your diningroom table is not made of timber, it's made of wood. But yes, the beams in your roof are timber as are the beams in a wooden ship. The latter are indeed referred to as "timbers".

Nonetheless, when a newly logged tree, still with its branches attached, is about to fall on your head, people don't yell "Wood!" They yell "Timber!"

Oh, and a log cabin is made of... logs.

I looked at the definition on dictionary.com, timber can mean the forest which is grown for logging, and the trees in it, or the processed article. *nods*

Timber, as defined in Cantr, is a log. Just a big log, a cut down tree.

Wood, as defined in Cantr, are pieces of the tree, or prepared pieces of a cut down tree.

Timber is used for only the log cabin, and it does exist as a resource. Timber was originally going to be "logs" made from prepared wood...

But, how would we explain that you need to glue together 1000 grams of wood to make a log... really? That's just backwards.

Well you could make all wood timber and then make the creation of wood a project, but that may just piss a lot of people off and add more hate posts to general discussion.

Changing all wood resources to timber would be HELL.

UTTER HELL.

So, no.

Or, we could just remove Timber altogether and make a cabin need wood >.>

But then what would make it different then a cottage?

Nothing at all, really.

Which makes all the more reason to remove it. Or just modify it. Because you know, you have a building AND a keep, for stone. That's gotta imply SOME amount of personalization...

The Industriallist wrote:Timber was also added to the game relatively recently, whereas wood has most likely been around since the beginning.

Really? When? More importantly, where? Aside from it's mention in log cabins?

Anthony Roberts wrote:But, how would we explain that you need to glue together 1000 grams of wood to make a log... really? That's just backwards.

Backwards, but makes a kind of sense, especially in cantr.

Why not make a timber a semi finished item, taking 500 wood and the adze and whatnot to make one. Then the log cabin could take the appropriate number of timbers to build, and everyone could be happy?

That would mean that the lower classes in the forests would have cottages, while the upper classes would have log cabins, as they can make the adzes required.

It's not like when you gather wood in real life, you gather it in individual grams. You grab chunks. I'd assume that most projects in cantr have the wood and time requirements to allow the builder to alter the wood to the needs of the project figured into it. By making timber a semifinished project, you're breaking down how and what they're doing to the wood they've gathered, not gluing it back together with and adze.