Cantr II Discussion Forum

One of my charries got bored while he was workin' (on charcoal), and so he made a little ditty about charcoal, just out of the blue. Then later, he was bored again, and started singin' about another project.

Do Cantrians know how to sing? I hope they do, 'cause its cool to sing.

Can't imagine why they wouldn't or couldn't be inclined to like melody/rythm etc.

Oh, a couple of mine have sung before. John's really getting his voice down

Yeah, I've seen singing even a long time ago in Cantr. I believe the convention is to put text between ~~, just like ** means third-person action descriptions (but see all the debates/constraints on that elsewhere on the forum ...)

I was just thinking about this thing... We lose a lot when not being able to lighten your dull toiling on the fields with a song, or travelling, or marching into the war, or just raising team spirit. Even if we write down the words, and rp the style of singing, it still isn't the same. And if one would tell people ooc to check the melody from another site, someone surely would start bitching about a CR breach. I think that's pretty dull. Well if it was some Britney Spears song or another silly thing then it might matter (besides they are copyrighted) but folk songs would be useful. We need music in Cantr!

*starts whistling Molly Malone*

Now of course we can make new lyrics... but if one wants to have an actual melody, it has to be taken from an outside source. Storing mp3's or even mids on Cantr server would freeze it in no time.

SekoETC wrote:I was just thinking about this thing... We lose a lot when not being able to lighten your dull toiling on the fields with a song, or travelling, or marching into the war, or just raising team spirit. Even if we write down the words, and rp the style of singing, it still isn't the same. And if one would tell people ooc to check the melody from another site, someone surely would start bitching about a CR breach. I think that's pretty dull. Well if it was some Britney Spears song or another silly thing then it might matter (besides they are copyrighted) but folk songs would be useful. We need music in Cantr!

*starts whistling Molly Malone*

Now of course we can make new lyrics... but if one wants to have an actual melody, it has to be taken from an outside source. Storing mp3's or even mids on Cantr server would freeze it in no time.

Oh you can definitely describe the singing to a very fair degree, everything from tone of voice, pitch, maybe even some of the melodic structure, the actual lyrics...just through roleplay. And of course, rp requires a bit of imagination, so why not imagine a bit, eh?

Yeah. You can do the melody and rhythm something like this:

Oooooh (elongating words) Ima(putting words together to make them sound faster) singin' a soong noww... Hey!

Yesss, and that looks quite silly. It's kinda like stuttering, you have to do it with style and if you do it for too long it starts annoying people.

And how is singing not like that?
Cantr players maybe think they miss out on not having songs. Cantr characters most likely don't, unless they've come into contact with songs they enjoyed.
Just RP them. If you want to shorten the lines, use short descriptions like 'speeds up'.

Hmmph! Seko doesn't like my singing!

I think Cantr does need music, and why should we not write it? I mean, it's about creating societies, right? and what societies do you know that do not have music? And if people put in a bit of effort and wern't stupid when writing the songs, they could be role played not half bad, and it would be fun, so why not?


by the way, nexit and netherspawn, I love your signatures, where did you come up with them?

as long as it doesn't consist of writing something recently heard on showtoons, Schme

Death, so called, is a thing which makes men weep, And yet a third of life is passed in sleep.
Lord Byron

Thanks Schme.

I made it up on the spot.

one of my characters once sang a song she made up...
it was pretty bad, but that was sort of the point of it.

griogal wrote:as long as it doesn't consist of writing something recently heard on showtoons, Schme

Death, so called, is a thing which makes men weep, And yet a third of life is passed in sleep.
Lord Byron

don't knock showtoons, my man, showtoons are the shit.


On the spot, eh Nexit? I would have thought you took it from something. Well, I think it is quite funny. Not quite as humourous as mine but......hehehe