TBR and Noniwrok, historical discussion. (No war talk)

[Bran-Muffin]

Post office was only used once actually. So already your scouting was off.

[AoM]

Even so, your plan would have been to pull back into the buildings, right? So no, we wouldn't have been caught off guard by your cunning tactics...



This is a lovely little what-if scenario isn't it? Oh well.

[Bran-Muffin]

Should I remind you of something recent?

[AoM]

Only if it's a PM. Wouldn't want you tarnishing this thread with your current event remarks.

[west]

EDIT: The plan I think, would have worked. Whether the soldiers would have been disciplined to carry it out would have been another story. Certainly not with Jules and Naleph sending mixed messages.

Then it wouldn't have worked. Plans are only good if circumstances are favorable, and that includes the people they involve pulling them off.

[AoM]

I agree West. Given the conditions at the time, it wouldn't have worked. In theory, it was viable. But communication failure destroyed any chances that it would have had for success.

[|william|]

What mixed plans? The plan was always the same. Only reason why Jules called it off was because most of the soldiers didn't have a clue as to what was going on. I recall Nayr sending the order to leave. A few soldiers followed but the rest were asking what was going on, or were asleep. It would have been a mess, he had to call it back. No one was really ready. Plus there were still healing foods to give out... but had everyone went and were ready, I think it would have been a success. If TBR would have chose to move out after the Karnon Army, it would have been a bloodshed. Heavy losses on both sides. But, as I said, the first plan fell apart mainly due to soldiers falling asleep or dying. Strange how that happened right when it was time to go.